It also provides a good comparative analysis of the two historians. The reign of hisham ibn abd almalik and the colla suny series in medieval middle east history by khalid yahya blankinship jun 28, 1994 4. I broached the subject of ibn ishaq s bio and showed him the web site where the english translation of the book can be downloaded. Fight everyone in the way of allah and kill those who disbelieve in allah. The real name of seerat ibn e ishaq is seeratul rasool allah. If theres any book a narration without an isnad will be accepted from, its ibn ishaq. What is known as the sirah of ibn hisham is actually the summary of the book of muhammad ibn ishaq born in 85 ah in medina and died in 151 ah in baghdad. Ibn ishaq also influenced later sira writers like ibn hisham and ibn sayyid alnas. Ibn ishaq s biography of muhammad is lost, but parts of it were used word for word at great length by ibn hisham and altabari in their works. It is rendition of sirat of the messenger of allah as compiled by ibn hashsham, the most authentic book of biography of. Allam ishaq was his contemporary who was also a prominent scholar of that era. Ibn hisham s contribution to ibn ishaq s original work is considered to be critical and useful.
Rizwi faizer is easily accessible from the following site and provides a firm platform to understand not only ibn ishaqs work, but also alwaqidi. Did ibn ishaq mention the summoning of the family event. This book was considered among pioneer book of biographies of prophet mohammad peace be upon him. Abu muhammad abd almalik bin hisham ibn ayyub alhimyari almuafiri alba. However, as i mentioned before, there are undoubtedly weak narrations in his book. Interpolations made by ibn hisham are said to be recognizable and can be deleted, leaving as a remainder, a socalled edited version of ibn ishaqs original text otherwise lost. Ibn ishaq hisham 458, also abu dawud 2686 other captives were ransomed, but uqba received special treatment because he had mocked muhammad at mecca. Ibn hisham also abbreviated, annotated, and sometimes altered the text of ibn ishaq, according to guillaume at p. The disgraceful and distressing things omitted from ibn.
The life of muhammad, ibn hisham furman university. His work is a translation of his own reconstruction of ibn ishaq. First published 1955, reissued in pakistan 1967, isbn 0 19 636033 1, seventeenth impression 2004. Ibn hisham was very careful when edited ibn ishaq s book he never changed or added a single word unless he was explaining or refuting a narration, and he would make it clear what he was modifying. Gustav weil stuttgart 1864 was the first published translation. God willing i shall begin this book with ismail son of ibrahim and mention those of his offspring who were the ancestors of god.
According to donner, the material in ibn hisham and altabari is virtually the same. Some of his works survive as quotations found in works by ibn ishaq, ibn hisham, ibn jarir altabari, abu nu. How authentic is the work of ibn ishaq how authentic is the work of ibn ishaq. Abu muhammad abd almalik ibn hesham was born in basra and died in egypt d218 ah.
Interpolations made by ibn hisham are said to be recognizable and can be deleted, leaving as a remainder, a socalled edited version of ibn ishaq s original text. The most authoritative biography of muhammad is titled the life of muhammad sirat rasul allah originally written by muhammad ibn ishaq around 760 ad. Ibn ishaq and ibn hisham muhammad ibn abdullah, who died in 632 ad, was the founder of islam. But an annotated version by ibn hisham does exist and this is the version that alfred guillaume 18881966 used to write his book the life of muhammad. Ibn ishaq was born in medina about eightyfive years after the hijra ah 85 and died in baghdad in ah 151. Guillaume, oxford university press, great clarendon street, oxford. The reign of hisham ibn abd almalik and the colla suny series in medieval middle east history. Pdf english translation of ibn hishams siratunnabi. Regarding altabaris narratives of muhammad, the translators state, the ealiest and most important of these sources was ibn ishaq, whose book on the prophet is usually known as the sirah. Theres at least one summary of ibn hishams book that i know of by the folio society thats light reading and less academically oriented. Alfred guillaumes authoritative translation of the sira of ibn ishaq presents in english the. Ibn hisham rawrote this biography through one person, ziyad albukari, ibn ishaqs book, which he wrote, was not in the form that it has today. Translation of ibn ishaq s sirat rasul allah a guillaume isbn.
Ibn ishaq abridgement of ibn hisham, alfred guillaume translator publisher. The main purpose of ibn hisham rewriting the biography of ibn ishaq was to summarize it. His crime was that he had thrown the entrails of a dead animal on muhammads back as he was praying, to the amusement of other meccans muslim 4422, ibn ishaq hisham 277. No copy of ibn ishaqs biography in its original form is now in existence, but it. In addition, controversies regarding accuracy are acknowledged by both ishaq and hisham.
Ibn hisham s asseera annabaviyya in the name of allah, the compassionate the merciful praise belongs to allah the lord of the worlds and may his blessing be upon our lord muhammad and his family, all of them the formula of blessing which follows every mention of the prophet is omitted hereafter. No copy of ibn ishaq s biography in its original form is now in existence, but it was extensively quarried by ibn hisharn died ah 2 or 218. Ibn hisham makes no secret in the introduction to his book of the fact that he omitted some of the material ibn ishaq included that reflected negatively upon muhammads character. Ibn ishaq has recorded in this book in which there is no mention of the apostle and about which the quran says nothing and which are not relevant to. Died 833 ce when did ibn ishaq supposedly complete his work.
Muhammads instructions to his men prior to a military raid. He was said to have mastered arabic philology in a way which only sibawayh had. Ibn ishaqs biography of muhammad countering islamism. The life of muhammad, a translation of ishaq s sirat rasul allah, with introduction and notes by a. They collected the lifespan of rasool allah saw from different teachers and people. Abu muhammad abd almalik bin hisham ibn ayyub alhimyari arabic. For example, the story about the satanic verses was not reported by ibn hisham. The book thus presents in english practically all that is known of the life of the.
It is translated by one of the greatest islamic scholars oxfords guillame, bringing to life the incredible research documents of ishaq a 8th century scholar. How come if prophet muhammad really existed, the earliest. Discussed here are ibn ishaq and his sirah, the various recensions of it, guillaumes translation, and ibn hisham. The fact is that what is popularly recognised as ibn ishaqs sirat is basically an. The unabriged version of ibn ishaq s history book does not exist anymore. No copy of that book remains, but around 800 ad, ibn hisham, a student of ibn ishaq reconstructed the biography from fragments and notes that he had collected. Look here its because you dont know how islamic knowledge works, there is nothing missing, there is something called chain of narration of any authenthic islamic source and that chain has to end to the prophet to be authentic, if the chain brea. His akhbar also contain chains of transmissions, or isnad. The translator used ibn hisham s abridgement and also included many additions and variants found in the writings of early authors. The book thus presents in english practically all that is known of the life of the prophet. No copy of ibn ishaqs biography in its original form is now in existence, but it was extensively quarried by ibn hisharn died ah 2 or 218.
Ibn hisham gave many authentic references about the life of the holy prophet muhammad pbuh. Ibn ishaq abridgement of ibn hisham, alfred guillaume translator. No copy of that book remains, but around 800 ad, ibn hisham, a student of ibn ishaq reconstructed. Professor guillaume is not merely offering a translation of the received text of the biography of muhammad, as recorded by ibn hisham from albakkai, from ibn ishaq. Professor guillaumes translation of the sira of ibn ishaq is now reissued. All types of books are available here like psychology urdu books,sociology urdu books,religious urdu books,islamic urdu books,are other books available here for free. Allama ibne ishaq and allama ibne hasham, both are the famous historian and islamic research scholars. Because of his tadlis, many scholars including muhammad albukhari hardly ever used his narrations in their sahih books.
A case study of muhammad and the jews in biographical literature this phd thesis by dr. The life of muhammad, a translation of ishaqs sirat rasul allah, with introduction and notes by a. For all purposes it is ibn hishams book and the editors of the standard arabic edition alsaqqa et al. Nearly years after the prophets death at around c. Some of those quoted texts were missing in ibn hishams work.
It is difficult not to get the impression that either ibn hisham or ibn ishaq wrote the sirah with the gospels open for inspiration. Ibn hishams seera asim iqbal 2nd islamic downloads. The present life of muhammad is by the earliest biographer whose work has survived. Ibn ishaq is considered the seminal book of seerah and the work he put into it is unparalleled. The first book illustrating life and works of muhammad s. This was written by mohammad bin ishaq, this was published in 8th century c. Ibn ishaq s work is lost and is now only known in the recensions of ibn hisham and altabari. From a despised minority the tbllowers of muhammad were now becoming the most powerful single force in arabia. The attacks on jewish tribes continued and much of the wealth of the country, which had previously been monopolized by jewish traders sirat rasoul allah by ibn ishag and landowners, was seized by the muslims.
429 416 589 485 1217 802 672 792 528 1178 353 531 656 653 1494 544 505 824 1176 1352 899 2 1005 258 439 37 101 256 1151 1009 1264 880 419